Cane or beet sugar, which is better? Cane sugar is the source of sweet life.

24.09.2019 Lenten dishes

Sugar is a special product that can be obtained from sugar beets or sugar cane, and the first option is significantly inferior to the second in terms of useful properties. The benefits and harms of cane sugar are actively discussed in the circles of doctors and nutritionists, but this does not decrease the popularity of the substance in the least.

Composition

The delicious cane-derived treat is much healthier than its white counterpart. This fact is determined by the unique composition of the product, which includes the following components.

  • Cane sugar is practically pure sucrose, which in the human body breaks down into glucose and fructose.
  • The potassium content helps to improve heart function and strengthen blood vessels. Thanks to this microelement, proteins and fats are absorbed better, the intestines are cleared more intensively and toxins are removed from the body.
  • Calcium strengthens bones and tooth enamel. Also, this component improves blood clotting and has a positive effect on the functioning of the brain.
  • - preserves youth, makes hair thick and shiny.
  • Copper strengthens the human immune system.
  • Phosphorus has a positive effect on the functioning of the brain and heart.
  • Iron strengthens the walls of blood vessels.

A sweet product obtained from cane is very useful for the body, therefore, in the absence of contraindications, it is recommended to include it in the diet.

Why cane sugar is good for you?

Brown sugar is less processed than white sugar. Therefore, much more valuable substances, useful microelements and vitamins are stored in it. The product acquires a specific dark color due to the fact that after processing the molasses, covering the sugar crystals, is preserved. It is in the molasses that the maximum amount of useful components is contained, which are transferred to the entire product as a whole. This explains the higher cost of raw cane.

The benefits of cane sugar are determined by the following features:

  • high in fiber, B vitamins, potassium, iron;
  • the product provides the body with glucose, which is necessary for the brain to function;
  • the use of the product has a beneficial effect on the functioning of many organs.

Regular consumption of sugar crystals obtained from cane can help cure liver and spleen diseases.

The harm of cane sugar

Despite its many beneficial properties, cane sugar can harm our body.

Those with a sweet tooth should remember that this delicacy becomes harmful if consumed in considerable quantities.

Sugar abuse can lead to the development of pathologies such as:

  • diabetes;
  • overweight;
  • atherosclerosis;
  • allergic reaction.

In diabetes, sugar consumption should be completely eliminated or reduced to a minimum. Limiting the sugar content in the diet should also be used for diseases such as pancreatitis, bronchial asthma, and oncology.

A cane treat, like regular sugar, can trigger the development of tooth decay.

An excess of sugar in the body can lead not only to an increase in excess fat folds, but also to disruption of metabolic processes. And this only reduces immunity.

According to the magazine "Polzateevo" and leading nutritionists, it is recommended to consume no more than 60 g of this product per day.

Cane sugar is just as good for children as it is for adults, but only in moderation.

How to tell real cane sugar from fake

To purchase a natural product, you need to have an idea of ​​the difference between a real cane treat and a fake one.

There are three ways to determine the authenticity of a product.

  1. The product cube must be thrown into plain warm water. If the liquid begins to turn golden, it means that we had to deal with the usual colored refined sugar. Real cane sugar doesn't color the water!
  2. You can make a syrup from cubes and add a drop of iodine to it. If the liquid has acquired a bluish tint, the product is natural. This is due to the presence of a small amount of starch in the natural substance, which enters into a chemical reaction with iodine.
  3. In order to distinguish a fake from a real product, sometimes it is enough to look at the manufacturer. Real cane sugar is produced in the USA, South America and Mauritius. If Russia, Moldova, etc. are indicated on the packaging as a manufacturer, then you can be sure that this product is a fake.

When purchasing a delicacy, you need to pay attention to the label, which indicates not only the color of the product (brown, black or brown), but also its one more characteristic - unrefined.

Having tried the original reed cubes only once, it will no longer be possible to confuse them with anything, and subsequently it will be easy to distinguish from a fake by taste.

Thus, sugar of any kind is essential for the normal functioning of the human body. And in order to avoid negative consequences from the use of this product, it is enough to adhere to the dosages recommended by experts.

Most people use sugar extensively in their daily lives. It is added to a variety of dishes and food products, and many do not even think about the benefits and dangers of such a substance. Nevertheless, in stores you can buy several types of sugar and sugar substitutes, which differ both in composition and even in their taste characteristics. So sugar can be made from different plants, including sugar cane and sugar beets, as well as stevia. Consider on this page www .. And also, which sugar is healthier: cane, beet or stevia?

Sugarcane composition

This plant has long been used to make sugar, many people are sure that sugar from it is much healthier than regular beetroot. It is believed that sugar cane contains 14-17% fiber, 63-65% water, approximately 17-22% juice dry matter. Also, this plant is a source of 0.1-1% reducing sugars, 1.5-2.5% soluble impurities and 12-20% sucrose.

Sugar beet - what is its composition?

As for sugar beet, this product is a source of 70-80% water, 3-5% fiber and hemicellulose, 20-22% carbohydrates (including 16-20% sugar), 1-2% nitrogenous substances and 0.5 -0.8% ash. One hundred grams of this vegetable contains 0.4 mg of vitamin PP, 0.1 mg of vitamin E, approximately 10 mg of ascorbic acid. Sugar beet contains vitamin B9 (13mkg), B6 ​​(0.07mg), B5 (0.1mg), B2 (0.04mg) and B1 (0.02mg). It also contains 0.01mg of beta carotene.

Sugar beet is a source of a number of minerals, represented by rubidium (453mkg), nickel (14mkg), cobalt (2mkg), vanadium (70mkg), boron (280mkg) and molybdenum (10mkg). It also contains fluorine (20mkg), chromium (20mg), manganese (0.66mg) and copper (140mg). Sugar beet contains a certain amount of iodine (7mkg), zinc (0.425mg), iron (1.4mg), sulfur (7mg) and chlorine (43mg). It also saturates the body with potassium (288mg), phosphorus (43mg), sodium (46mg), magnesium (22mg) and calcium (37mg).

Stevia - chemical composition

Stevia herb has a fairly diverse composition. It contains 18% diterpene glycosides, 30-45% flavonoids (more than twelve varieties), 10-15% chlorophylls and xanthophylls, 2.5-3% oxycinnamic acids. Also, this plant contains 1.6% -2% oligosaccharides, 3-5% free sugars, 1.5-3% amino acids (of which 8 are irreplaceable). Also in this herb there are 0.18% of mineral compounds (zinc, chromium, phosphorus, iron, calcium, magnesium, selenium, sodium and iodine) and 0.1% of a complex of vitamins (A, C, D, E, K and P) ...

Which sugar is healthier than cane sugar, beet sugar, or stevia sugar?

Experts say that about a third of all sugar in the world is produced from sugar beets, and the remaining 70% comes from cane sugar, which grows in the tropics and subtropics. In principle, both of these types of sugar can be refined or unrefined. But it is basically impossible to find unrefined beet sugar on sale.

If we compare the beneficial qualities of refined beet sugar and refined cane sugar, then they are practically the same and equal to "zero". After all, the processing of such products during manufacture leads to the elimination of the lion's share of useful substances from it. Also, both of these types of sugar have the same effect on the body.

If we talk about the beneficial qualities of unrefined cane sugar, then, of course, they are slightly higher than those of refined products. However, the unique properties of such a product are greatly exaggerated. Scientists claim that the amount of vitamins and minerals in cane sugar is negligible - slightly more than in a glass of water.

In addition, cane sugar can be harmful to health if it is not transported correctly (for example, next to poison from rodents, which is often practiced on ships).

As for stevia, it is a plant that is popular among fans of proper and balanced nutrition. It is believed that such a product can have a positive effect on health, namely, to strengthen the immune system, improve metabolic processes, etc. In addition, stevia is characterized by zero calorie content, and its sweetness is due to the presence of unique glycosides in its composition. Funds based on it can be used as a sugar substitute in diabetes mellitus.

Some scientists argue that stevia is able to optimize blood pressure and digestive processes, prevent the development of cancer, defeat allergies and other pathological conditions.

It is worth noting that to date, not a single fully confirmed negative quality of stevia is known, except perhaps for allergic reactions. The only significant drawback of this product is its relatively high cost. Of course, it is better not to consume such leaves during pregnancy and breastfeeding. You also need to remember that counterfeits are often found on the market.

If you are not suffering from any health problems, you may well be consuming regular sugar. But stevia, of course, is a worthy alternative to such a product, it can be useful for diabetics and people suffering from obesity.

The desire now, immediately, without fail, to eat at least something sweet periodically arises in every representative of the Homo sapiens species. Our mind fiercely resists these impulses, because it is declared one of the main killers of health, and, more importantly, a thin waist, which means beauty.

Cane sugar brown, which has recently appeared on the shelves of Russian supermarkets, has been declared a kind of panacea, both sweet and healthy. From the point of view of modern science, excessive consumption of sugar threatens with a violation of fat metabolism and the development of atherosclerosis.

The norm of sugars, according to the WHO recommendation, should not exceed 10% of all calories in the daily diet. For men it is no more than 60g, for women - no more than 50g per day. It would seem that we all can easily fit into these standards, which, at first glance, are not scary at all. However, do not forget that we put a very small part of the sugar diet in tea. We drink soda with pleasure, without thinking about the amount of "sweet death" in our favorite products. Fructose is also sugar, so we should throw sweet berries and fruits into our daily piggy bank. In addition, sugar is a great spice that not only enhances the taste of any dish, but also contributes to a longer shelf life. Therefore, you can find it in the composition of completely "non-sugar" products - meat and fish, marinades, sweet and sour sauces.

Can the use cane sugar make our existence easier without depriving it of sweetness? And to what brown sugar should you give preference?

The real and imaginary benefits of cane sugar

Brown sugar is several times more expensive than the white refined cane and beet sugar we are used to. Why should we pay more for a product whose cost is much lower than that of? From the filing of numerous media outlets, we have firmly learned that all refined foods are harmful to our body. At the same time, we forget that refining is also the removal of unwanted impurities that also pose a threat to health.

Let's see what is really different Brown sugar from white, and is it worth emptying our wallets to buy it.

Unrefined cane sugar and white sugar: comparative characteristics

When buying refined sugar, we cannot determine what origin it is. It doesn't matter, because white sugar, both cane and beet sugar, does not differ in composition and taste. If you see brown sugar on the counter, then it is made from cane sugar. Unrefined beet sugar is not marketed due to its unattractive taste and aroma.

So, according to the USDA Nutrient database, per 100g of product:

  • calorie content of white sugar - 387 kcal, brown sugar - 377 kcal; conclusion - the calorie content of a refined and unrefined product is practically the same;
  • white sugar is 99.91g, cane sugar is 96.21g; conclusion - the composition of refined and unrefined sugar contains almost the same amount of carbohydrates, therefore, they have the same effect on the body, from the point of view of the violation of fat metabolism and the provocation of atherosclerosis;
  • white sugar contains 1 mg calcium, 0.01 mg iron and 2 mg potassium; brown sugar contains 85mg calcium, 1.91mg iron, 346mg potassium, 29mg magnesium, 22mg phosphorus, 39mg sodium, 0.18mg zinc; conclusion - brown sugar, unlike white sugar, contains a large amount of minerals necessary for us;
  • white sugar contains 0.019mg of vitamin B2; unrefined cane sugar contains 0.008mg of vitamin B1, 0.007mg B2, 0.082mg B3, 0.026mg B6, 1 μg B9; conclusion - brown sugar is many times superior to white in vitamin composition.
The main takeaway about the health benefits of cane sugar consists in the fact that it is rich in vitamin and mineral composition of brown sugar. Together with sweet calories, we get B vitamins and minerals in the appendix. However, the amount of these beneficial constituents in unrefined sugar is not regulated by standards and can vary greatly. At the same time, it must be borne in mind that replacing white sugar with brown sugar will not bring us a decrease in the calorie content of the diet and will not save us from gaining excess weight.

Another reason for using it is the unusual, pronounced aroma and taste of this product. Gourmets all over the world consider brown sugar to be the ideal sweetener for tea and coffee, allowing them to fully reveal the taste of their favorite drinks. It is not for nothing that in Europe it is called a tea house and is served in expensive restaurants.

Choosing brown sugar: a reminder to the consumer

Buying cane sugar is not a problem today. The question is, what kind of it to choose in order to get the maximum possible benefit.

When choosing cane sugar, it must be remembered that brown color is by no means always an indicator of the naturalness, unrefined product. Natural sugar acquires its specific taste, color and aroma thanks to molasses, which contains the very substances due to which unrefined sugar is considered healthier than usual. However, brown sugar is not always natural and unrefined. Often, it acquires a color spectrum due to dyes and a special production method.

Types of cane sugar

Demerara sugar- the type of brown sugar, which is most often sold in our stores, a product of golden brown color. can be both natural unrefined and white refined sugar mixed with molasses. Read the label carefully!

Muscovado sugar- produced with different amounts of molasses. The more molasses, the darker it is. Muscovado crystals are smaller than Demerara, they are sticky, with a strong caramel flavor. Dark black muscovado with a very strong molasses scent.

Turbinado sugar- dry large crystals from golden to brown color. This natural raw cane sugar is produced by partial molasses removal using steam and water.

Soft molasses sugar or Black Barbados sugar- natural unrefined raw cane sugar containing a large amount of molasses. It is a soft, moist, very dark sugar with a very strong aroma.

By choosing cane sugar, look for the word "unrefined" on the label. Only in this case will your joy from sweetness have a hint of usefulness.

Bon Appetit!

Isabella Likhareva

Brown sugar has long been in great demand among health conscious people. What is the secret of this product, how does it differ from all the usual white sugar, and what benefits does its use promise to the body? Let's figure it out.

Brown sugar - what is it?

Brown sugar is a processed sugar cane product that retains the color and taste of the molasses included in cane juice. A distinctive feature of brown sugar is that it does not undergo bleaching during the production process.

A bit of history

In ancient times, brown sugar crystals extracted from cane were the first sugar that people began to use in their diet. The first mentions of this wonderful plant date back to the times of Alexander the Great. The homeland of cane sugar is considered to be India, from which this product spread throughout Europe. In the 16th century, cane brown sugar was a symbol of luxury and wealth. This product, which became the cause of the wars of conquest, was an integral guest of the royal table. In modern times, brown sugar is not something unusual and outlandish, because everyone can afford it.

White and brown sugar: what are the differences?

Brown sugar has a number of undeniable advantages over its white counterpart. White sugar is a refined product obtained from the chemical processing of brown sugar. To obtain it, various bleaching agents are used, some of which, "settling" in white sugar, penetrate the human body with it. Brown sugar, the recipe for which does not provide for this kind of cleaning, is more natural and environmentally friendly.

The brown color of sugar is associated with the presence in its composition of components such as molasses or molasses, which have a lot of useful minerals. Therefore, brown cane sugar is significantly ahead of white in terms of biological value.

Brown sugar: benefits and chemical composition of the product

85-98% of cane sugar, depending on the country of origin, consists of sucrose. In addition, the constituent components of this product are a number of trace elements useful for the human body.

So, potassium, which is part of brown sugar, helps to cleanse the intestines, removes accumulated toxins, regulates blood pressure and is an active participant in the metabolism of fats and proteins. Without this mineral, normal heart function is impossible.

As you know, calcium, which is also present in unrefined cane sugar, is responsible for the condition of teeth and bones, contributes to their strengthening. It is also of great importance for the full functioning of the nervous system and the blood coagulation system.

Zinc is called upon to normalize fat metabolism. In addition, this mineral, which is an integral component of brown sugar, takes part in the processes of hematopoiesis, promotes the growth of skin and hair cells, and is also necessary for wound healing.

Copper is called to improve the activity of the immune system, to activate the body's defenses, and magnesium is designed to accelerate the course of metabolism and prevent the process of stone formation. Phosphorus, which is also rich in brown sugar, is essential for the normal functioning of the heart muscle and brain. He also participates in metabolic processes, being an integral component of cells and, above all, cell membranes.

Iron, which is also found in cane sugar, is essential for the circulatory system to function. By the way, in brown sugar, in comparison with white, refined, the concentration of iron is almost 10 times higher.

Thus, brown sugar, the benefits of which are undeniable, must be included in the diet of every person who is not indifferent to their health.

Scope of application

Cane brown sugar belongs to complex, complex carbohydrates, therefore, the process of its assimilation by the body takes place at a slow pace. For this reason, such sugar will benefit all those who are struggling with extra pounds. Moreover, according to modern nutritionists, this product can be safely used on salt-free, low-fat, and protein-free diets, but this must be done in moderation. So, without harm to the diet, you can consume about 50 grams per day. brown sugar.

Also, unrefined cane sweetness is widely used for recovery after exercise, in a healthy diet. Due to the mass of its useful properties and high quality, this product is an indispensable element of baby food, and should also be included in the diet of people prone to allergic reactions.

Brown sugar is used as an additive to hot drinks. So, he will not only add sweetness to tea or coffee, but also give them an incomparable aroma. Also, cane sugar is added to canned food, marinades, baked goods, desserts, sweets, ice cream.

Calorie content

Cane brown sugar has about the same calorie content as white beet sugar. If the modest measure of its consumption is not observed, this product is also able to quickly go into body fat.

So, if the calorie content is 100 gr. white refined sugar is 387 kcal, then unrefined brown sweetness - 377 kcal. As you can see, the difference is insignificant. However, if you wish, you can find brown cane sugar on sale, the calorie content of which is 200 times less. A similar effect is achieved by adding aspartame, an artificial sweetener, to the product.

Caution, fake!

Unfortunately, in modern times, there is a high probability when buying cane sugar you will encounter a fake. There are two ways to recognize a poor-quality product, but, unfortunately, this can be done exclusively at home.

So, method number 1. To carry it out, you will need a bottle of iodine. Brown sugar should be diluted in a glass of water and a couple of drops of iodine should be dripped into it. Real brown cane sweetness, reacted with iodine, takes on a blue tint. If this did not happen, then this is not a real product, but a fake.

Method number 2. For the second experiment, as in the first case, it is necessary to dissolve cane sugar in warm water. If it is quality sugar, then the water will remain colorless. If you have ordinary caramel on your hands, then the liquid will turn brown.

Brown sugar "Mistral" is in special demand among consumers. This brand has established itself exclusively on the positive side, since the goods produced under its brand are always distinguished by their high quality.

Alternative to brown sugar

Many people strive to completely eliminate high-calorie sweets from their diet. In this regard, the question of how to replace brown sugar is very relevant. There are several options here.

  • fresh sugar cane juice, which contains brown unrefined sugar, albeit in an organic, absolutely safe form;
  • natural honey;
  • vegetables and fruits, which contain a high level of glucose (apples, apricots, bananas);
  • dried fruits (raisins, banana chips).

Thus, brown cane sugar is a very healthy product, the use of which has a beneficial effect on the functioning of all organs and systems of the body.

The harm and benefits of this product are not known to many, although more and more often, fans of a healthy diet buy it. It is believed to be less nutritious and less harmful. After all, sugar has long been called the "white death" because of its ability to cause various diseases. Many people try to give up this product altogether, because they monitor their health. But doctors warn that the body needs glucose. It is very important for the functioning of the brain. Therefore, unrefined is an essential product on the table for those people who want to be healthy. Moreover, you can buy it in any supermarket.

What is brown sugar

How it differs from the usual beetroot - few know. Refined white sugar is more readily available because it is cheaper to produce, and the sugar beet from which it is made grows everywhere. But in order for sugar to become usable, it undergoes a complex process of refining and bleaching. That is why it is considered so harmful. And its brown variety is made from sugar cane.

Its homeland is India, and many hundreds of years ago it became popular in Europe. This sweetness is obtained by boiling, and it does not need bleaching at all. The brown mass has a pleasant molasses smell and is ready for use without additional processing. But it still costs more than regular sugar. The price of overseas sweets is more than 100 rubles per kilogram.

Why brown sugar is good for you

Thanks to the gentle processing method, this sweetness is not only tasty, but also healthy. It retains all the vitamins and minerals contained in the cane. How is it different from regular cane sugar? Its harm and benefits are the subject of much debate. But it has been proven to have the following benefits:


Could this product be harmful?

Healthy food advocates try to buy only it. They believe that reed is best suited to maintain health and a beautiful figure, and the benefits of this product are in many cases exaggerated. After all, for example, its calorie content is not much lower than that of a regular one. Therefore, those who want to lose weight should also reduce the rate of consumed sweetness, even if it is because it, when consumed in large quantities, contributes to obesity. This is because the glucose found in cane sugar immediately enters the bloodstream and gives the body energy. If a person does not spend it, then it is put aside. Therefore, the opinion that cane sugar can be consumed in large quantities is incorrect. Like white, it can cause metabolic disorders, a disorder in the work of the pancreas, decreased immunity, diabetes mellitus and atherosclerosis.

What is cane sugar

The brown color is given to it by molasses. The more it is, the darker the product. Therefore, some manufacturers who want to make money dye regular sugar brown. Its price turns out to be much higher, but there is no benefit - only harm.

Unrefined sugar is considered to be the best, since more nutrients are stored in it. It is he who is popular with fans of healthy eating. There are several types of brown sugar:

  • The Demerara variety comes from South America. It is distinguished by sticky wet crystals. This sugar is the mildest in action and is considered the most beneficial.
  • Muscovado variety has a pronounced caramel flavor. It is moist and sticky in consistency, dark in color.
  • Turbinado variety - with large dry particles. During production, it is partially purified.
  • Barbados black is the most prized. It has a very dark color and a damp, sticky consistency.

Why is cane sugar so popular

After this product was brought to Russia several centuries ago, it was available only to the rich. And in recent years, it has appeared on the shelves of our stores. But not everyone now knows what cane sugar is. Its harm and benefits are still the subject of controversy. But experienced chefs add only it to baked goods, because it gives pies and buns a unique exquisite taste and aroma. Also, bartenders prefer to make cocktails and coffee only with cane sugar.

How to distinguish a fake

In order not to buy ordinary colored sugar, you need to know what to look for when buying:

  • it must be indicated on the package that it is unrefined;
  • real cane sugar cannot be sold in the form of perfectly even briquettes or homogeneous sand, since all of its crystals have a different shape;
  • this sugar is produced only in South America, the USA or Mauritius.